Imbalance is not an impediment: understanding the natural imbalances of Sex and B-chromosomes in species by understanding cancer karyotypes

  1. 1.  The Winnower, New York, NY

Cancers are defined by abnormal karyotypes, displaying ever-changing structural and numerical abnormalities.  Such plasticity of the karyotype underlies the evolution of cancer cells (Navin et al. 2011, Pavelka, Rancati, and Li 2010, Lee et al. 2011, Nicholson and Duesberg 2009).  Karyotype alterations are also responsible for phenotypic variation and evolution in yeast (Rancati et al. 2008, Pavelka, Rancati, and Li 2010) and arguably of species in general (King 1993, McCarthy 2008).  Because the alterations in the karyotypes of cancer cells have been shown to be non-random and stable within limits (Li et al. 2009, Nicholson and Duesberg 2009, Gebhart and Liehr 2000, Mertens et al. 1997), recently it has been proposed that carcinogenesis may be a form of speciation (Duesberg et al. 2011, Vincent 2010)  

Typical species karyotypes, however, are largely composed of balanced karyotypes. While chromosomal balance appears to be the standard, there exist two classes of chromosomes that display a natural existing imbalance, namely, sex chromosomes and B-chromosomes.  To understand the behavior of these “normal” aneuploidies I compare and contrast their behavior to aneuploid chromosomes in cancer.

Sex Chromosomes and B-Chromosomes

Sex chromosomes display different ratios per species per sex determination system (i.e. XY in mammals and XO in flies).  Such chromosomal imbalance is thought to be sustainable because it is balanced by dosage compensation where XX females transcriptionally inactivate one X chromosome and XY or XO males show double the transcriptional activity.  Recent work however has called this sweeping conclusion into question (Mank, Hosken, and Wedell 2011).  Accordingly, X chromosomes in humans previously thought to be completely inactivated show over 15% of genes without dosage compensation (Carrel and Willard 2005).  Moreover, chicken and zebra finch show no sex chromosome dosage compensation (Itoh et al. 2010, Ellegren et al. 2007) nor does silkworm (Zha et al. 2009, Arunkumar, Mita, and Nagaraju 2009).  In fact, expression differences in sex chromosomes may actually confer differences in sex determination (Smith et al. 2009).

Another natural chromosomal imbalance is seen in B-chromosomes.  The definition of B-chromosomes changes with author and year, however it is sufficient to state that they are unique extra chromosomes.   B-chromosomes, like sex chromosomes, are thought to have originated from autosomes (Keyl and Hagele 1971, Wilkes et al. 1995) or sex chromosomes (Camacho, Sharbel, and Beukeboom 2000).  They are present in numerous different organisms from fungi to mammalia and can range in size and structure from a small fragment to the largest chromosome in the karyotype (Gregory 2005).  While B-chromosomes have been identified in various species, their functionality remains largely unknown.  It is known that B- chromosomes can change the expression levels of A-chromosomes (Kirk and Jones 1970, Ayonoadu and Rees 1971) and accordingly, induce phenotypic changes such as different sex traits in cichlids (Yoshida et al. 2011) or leaf color in corn (Staub 1987).  Certain changes conferred by B-chromosomes, have shown corresponding adaptive effects.  Avena sativa with B-chromosomes shows resistance to rust (Dherawattana and Sadanaga 1973) and the fungus Nectria haematococca with B-chromosomes are resistant to antibiotics (Miao, Covert, and VanEtten 1991, Miao, Matthews, and VanEtten 1991).  The observations in sex and B-chromosomes beget the question: is perfect balance necessary?

Are aneuploid and/or marker chromosomes in cancer the same as B-chromosomes?

The benefits of aneuploidy in cancer, largely thought as a detriment, are slowly being appreciated (Pavelka, Rancati, and Li 2010).  Similarly, B-chromosomes which were once thought to “have no useful function at all to the species carrying them.”(Ostergen 1945), appear to persist because of potential advantageous effects.  Indeed, the “drive” of B-chromosomes, that is an increase in frequency in species, generally increases over time (Cavallaro et al. 2000, Araújo et al. 2002).  Further, listing the behavior between B- chromosomes and aneuploid marker chromosomes in cancer shows a remarkable concordance (Table 1).  Such a similarity enforces the idea that carcinogenesis is perhaps a form of speciation and that karyotypic alterations such as B-chromosomes and sex chromosomes are the same as aneuploid marker chromosomes in cancer.

Table 1. B-chromosomes vs. aneuploid/marker chromosomes in cancer



marker chr.



Only a minority are maintained in karyotype



(Gregory 2005, Li et al. 2009)

Degree of stability in mitosis correlated with chromosome size



Nicholson, unpublished

(Hewitt 1979)

Increase in strucutural change/ recombination



(Camacho et al. 2002, Fabarius, Hehlmann, and Duesberg 2003, Janssen et al. 2011)

Pleiotropic effect on genome expression



(Upender et al. 2004, Ruiz-Rejon, Posse, and Oliver 1980)

Slowed growth/development



(Torres et al. 2007, Harvey and Hewitt 1979)

Confers adaptive potential



(Lee et al. 2011, Dherawattana and Sadanaga 1973)



Araújo, S. M. S. R., S. G. Pompolo, F. Perfectti, and J. P. M. Camacho. 2002. "Integra\ntion of a B chromosome into the A genome of a wasp, revisited." Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences no. 269 (1499):1475-1478. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2002.2040.

Arunkumar, K. P., K. Mita, and J. Nagaraju. 2009. "The silkworm Z chromosome is enrich\ned in testis-specific genes." Genetics no. 182 (2):493-501. doi: 10.1534/genetics.108.099994.

Ayonoadu, U. W., and H. Rees. 1971. "The effects of B chromosomes on the nuclear pheno\ntype in root meristems of maize." Heredity no. 27 (3):365-383.

Camacho, J. P. M., M. Bakkali, J. M. Corral, J. Cabrero, M. D. López-León, I. Aranda, \nA. Martín-Alganza-Alganza, and F. Perfectti. 2002. "Host recombination is dependent on the degree of parasitism." Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences no. 269 (1505):2173-2177. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2002.2135.

Camacho, J. P., T. F. Sharbel, and L. W. Beukeboom. 2000. "B-chromosome evolution." Ph\nilos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci no. 355 (1394):163-78. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2000.0556.

Carrel, Laura, and Huntington F. Willard. 2005. "X-inactivation profile reveals extens\nive variability in X-linked gene expression in females." Nature no. 434 (7031):400-404. doi:

Cavallaro, Z. I., L. A. Bertollo, F. Perfectti, and J. P. Camacho. 2000. "Frequency in\ncrease and mitotic stabilization of a B chromosome in the fish Prochilodus lineatus." Chromosome Res no. 8 (7):627-34.

Dherawattana, A, and K Sadanaga. 1973. "Cytogenetics of a crown, rust-resistant hexapl\noid oat with 42 + 2 fragment chromosomes." Crop Sciences no. 13:591-594.

Duesberg, P., D. Mandrioli, A. McCormack, and J. M. Nicholson. 2011. "Is carcinogenesi\ns a form of speciation?" Cell Cycle no. 10 (13):2100-14.

Ellegren, H., L. Hultin-Rosenberg, B. Brunstrom, L. Dencker, K. Kultima, and B. Scholz\n. 2007. "Faced with inequality: chicken do not have a general dosage compensation of sex-linked genes." BMC Biol no. 5:40. doi: 10.1186/1741-7007-5-40.

Fabarius, A., R. Hehlmann, and P. H. Duesberg. 2003. "Instability of chromosome struct\nure in cancer cells increases exponentially with degrees of aneuploidy." Cancer Genet Cytogenet no. 143 (1):59-72.

Gebhart, Erich, and Thomas Liehr. 2000. "Patterns of genomic imbalances in human solid\n tumors." Int J Oncol no. 16:383-399.

Gregory, T. Ryan. 2005. The evolution of the genome. Burlington, MA: Elsevier Academic\n.

Harvey, A. W., and G. M. Hewitt. 1979. "B Chromosomes slow development in a grasshoppe\nr." Heredity no. 42 (3):397-401.

Hewitt, Godfrey M. 1979. Orthoptera : grasshoppers and crickets, Animal cytogenetics. \nBerlin: Gebrüder Borntraeger.

Itoh, Y., K. Replogle, Y. H. Kim, J. Wade, D. F. Clayton, and A. P. Arnold. 2010. "Sex\n bias and dosage compensation in the zebra finch versus chicken genomes: general and specialized patterns among birds." Genome Res no. 20 (4):512-8. doi: 10.1101/gr.102343.109.

Janssen, A., M. van der Burg, K. Szuhai, G. J. Kops, and R. H. Medema. 2011. "Chromoso\nme segregation errors as a cause of DNA damage and structural chromosome aberrations." Science no. 333 (6051):1895-8. doi: 10.1126/science.1210214.

Keyl, HG, and K Hagele. 1971. "B chromosomen bei Chironomus." Chromosoma no. 35:403-41\n7.

King, Max. 1993. Species evolution:  the role of chromosome change. Cambridge: Cambrid\nge University Press.

Kirk, David, and R. Neil Jones. 1970. "Nuclear genetic activity in B-chromosome rye, i\nn terms of the quantitative interrelationships between nuclear protein, nuclear RNA and histone." Chromosoma no. 31 (2):241-254. doi: 10.1007/bf00285151.

Lee, A. J., D. Endesfelder, A. J. Rowan, A. Walther, N. J. Birkbak, P. A. Futreal, J. \nDownward, Z. Szallasi, I. P. Tomlinson, M. Howell, M. Kschischo, and C. Swanton. 2011. "Chromosomal Instability Confers Intrinsic Multidrug Resistance." Cancer Res no. 71 (5):1858-1870. doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-10-3604.

Li, L., A. A. McCormack, J. M. Nicholson, A. Fabarius, R. Hehlmann, R. K. Sachs, and P\n. H. Duesberg. 2009. "Cancer-causing karyotypes: chromosomal equilibria between destabilizing aneuploidy and stabilizing selection for oncogenic function." Cancer Genet Cytogenet no. 188 (1):1-25.

Mank, Judith E., David J. Hosken, and Nina Wedell. 2011. "Some inconvenient truths abo\nut sex chromosome dosage compensation and the potential role of sexual conflict." Evolution no. 65 (8):2133-2144. doi: 10.1111/j.1558-5646.2011.01316.x.

McCarthy, E. 2008. On the Origins of New Forms of Life - A New Theory: Macroevolution.\nnet.

Mertens, F, B Johansson, M Hoeglund, and F Mitelman. 1997. "Chromosomal imbalance maps\n of malignant solid tumors: a cytogentic survey of 3185 neoplasms." Cancer Res no. 57:2765-2780.

Miao, V. P., S. F. Covert, and H. D. VanEtten. 1991. "A fungal gene for antibiotic res\nistance on a dispensable ("B") chromosome." Science no. 254 (5039):1773-6.

Miao, V. P., D. E. Matthews, and H. D. VanEtten. 1991. "Identification and chromosomal\n locations of a family of cytochrome P-450 genes for pisatin detoxification in the fungus Nectria haematococca." Mol Gen Genet no. 226 (1-2):214-23.

Navin, N., J. Kendall, J. Troge, P. Andrews, L. Rodgers, J. McIndoo, K. Cook, A. Stepa\nnsky, D. Levy, D. Esposito, L. Muthuswamy, A. Krasnitz, W. R. McCombie, J. Hicks, and M. Wigler. 2011. "Tumour evolution inferred by single-cell sequencing." Nature. doi: 10.1038/nature09807.

Nicholson, J.M., and P Duesberg. 2009. "On the karyotypic origin and evolution of canc\ner cells." Cancer Genet Cytogenet no. 194 (2):96-110.

Ostergen, G. 1945. "Parasitic nature of extra fragment chromosomes." Botaniska Notiser\n no. 2:157-163.

Pavelka, N., G. Rancati, and R. Li. 2010. "Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde: role of aneuploidy i\nn cellular adaptation and cancer." Curr Opin Cell Biol no. 22 (6):809-15. doi: 10.1016/

Rancati, G., N. Pavelka, B. Fleharty, A. Noll, R. Trimble, K. Walton, A. Perera, K. St\naehling-Hampton, C. W. Seidel, and R. Li. 2008. "Aneuploidy underlies rapid adaptive evolution of yeast cells deprived of a conserved cytokinesis motor." Cell no. 135 (5):879-93. doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2008.09.039.

Ruiz-Rejon, M, F Posse, and J Oliver. 1980. "The B-chromosome system of Scilla autumna\nlis (Liliaceae): effects at the isozyme level." Chromosoma no. 79:341-348.

Smith, C. A., K. N. Roeszler, T. Ohnesorg, D. M. Cummins, P. G. Farlie, T. J. Doran, a\nnd A. H. Sinclair. 2009. "The avian Z-linked gene DMRT1 is required for male sex determination in the chicken." Nature no. 461 (7261):267-71. doi: 10.1038/nature08298.

Staub, Rick W. 1987. "Leaf striping correlated with the presence of B chromosomes in m\naize." Journal of Heredity no. 78 (2):71-74.

Torres, E. M., T. Sokolsky, C. M. Tucker, L. Y. Chan, M. Boselli, M. J. Dunham, and A.\n Amon. 2007. "Effects of aneuploidy on cellular physiology and cell division in haploid yeast." Science no. 317 (5840):916-24. doi: 10.1126/science.1142210.

Upender, M. B., J. K. Habermann, L. M. McShane, E. L. Korn, J. C. Barrett, M. J. Difil\nippantonio, and T. Ried. 2004. "Chromosome transfer induced aneuploidy results in complex dysregulation of the cellular transcriptome in immortalized and cancer cells." Cancer Res no. 64 (19):6941-9.

Vincent, M. D. 2010. "The animal within: carcinogenesis and the clonal evolution of ca\nncer cells are speciation events sensu stricto." Evolution no. 64 (4):1173-83. doi: 10.1111/j.1558-5646.2009.00942.x.

Wilkes, Timothy M., Michael G. Francki, Peter Langridge, Angela Karp, R. Neil Jones, a\nnd John W. Forster. 1995. "Analysis of rye B-chromosome structure using fluorescence<i>in situ</i> hybridization (FISH)." Chromosome Research no. 3 (8):466-472. doi: 10.1007/bf00713960.

Yoshida, Kohta, Yohey Terai, Shinji Mizoiri, Mitsuto Aibara, Hidenori Nishihara, Masak\natsu Watanabe, Asato Kuroiwa, Hirohisa Hirai, Yuriko Hirai, Yoichi Matsuda, and Norihiro Okada. 2011. "B Chromosomes Have a Functional Effect on Female Sex Determination in Lake Victoria Cichlid Fishes." PLoS Genet no. 7 (8):e1002203. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1002203.

Zha, X., Q. Xia, J. Duan, C. Wang, N. He, and Z. Xiang. 2009. "Dosage analysis of Z ch\nromosome genes using microarray in silkworm, Bombyx mori." Insect Biochem Mol Biol no. 39 (5-6):315-21. doi: 10.1016/j.ibmb.2008.12.003.




This article and its reviews are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and redistribution in any medium, provided that the original author and source are credited.